New York Cigarillos

Shop Guide

Historic NYC Tobacconists: Barclay Rex, Nat Sherman and More

New York City's most famous historic tobacconists are Barclay Rex, a family business since 1910, and Nat Sherman, whose landmark 42nd Street townhouse operated until 2020.

Updated · New York Cigarillos Editorial Team

Find NYC Cigar Lounges →
Historic NYC tobacconists: a cedar walk-in humidor full of cigar boxes

New York once had tobacconists on nearly every block. Today a few historic NYC tobacconists carry that tradition, and a few famous names live on only in memory. We are independent and not affiliated with any of these businesses.

Historic NYC Tobacconists at a Glance

NameFoundedStatusKnown for
Barclay Rex1910Open — 126 Pearl Street, Financial DistrictFamily-owned for four generations; shop, lounge and cigar club
Nat Sherman1930Townhouse closed in 202042nd Street townhouse off Fifth Avenue; Nat Sherman cigars and cigarettes
Davidoff of GenevaSwiss brandMadison Avenue shopPremium Davidoff cigars and accessories

Quick answer: Barclay Rex, founded in 1910 and still family-owned, is New York's most historic working tobacconist. Nat Sherman's famous 42nd Street townhouse closed in 2020 after its owner Altria shut the business; some Nat Sherman cigar brands continue under new owners.

Barclay Rex

Barclay Rex was founded in 1910 by Vincent Nastri, an Italian immigrant pipe maker. The shop is named after its first location near Barclay Street and the family's Great Dane, Rex. It moved to Maiden Lane in 1949, later to Broad Street, and in 2016 to 126 Pearl Street, where the family took the entire four-story building. Today the ground floor holds the shop and walk-in humidor, the lower level a lounge, and the second floor a members' cigar club with humidified lockers. The business is run by Vanessa Nastri, the fourth generation, who took over in 2019, and it is often described as the last family-owned tobacconist in New York.

Nat Sherman

Nat Sherman opened his tobacco business in New York in 1930. The company became famous for its own cigarettes and cigars and for its flagship store, known as the Nat Sherman Townhouse, on 42nd Street just off Fifth Avenue, opposite the New York Public Library. Altria acquired the company in 2017. In August 2020, Altria announced that Nat Sherman International would cease operations, and the Midtown store closed that fall. In 2021 a company formed by former Nat Sherman employees acquired several of its premium cigar brands, including Timeless, Metropolitan, Epoca and Ancora.

Madison Avenue

Madison Avenue is home to premium brand boutiques, including a Davidoff of Geneva shop. Brand boutiques offer walk-in humidors and accessories, though smoking policies vary by location.

Tips for Visiting NYC Tobacconists

  • Bring ID — the legal age to buy tobacco in New York is 21.
  • Expect NYC prices — minimum-price laws and taxes make cigars cost more than in most states; see NYC cigar laws.
  • Ask about lounges — some shops have legal smoking lounges; see NYC cigar lounges.
  • Store purchases properly — if you're traveling, a travel humidor helps; see cigar humidors.

Why So Many Shops Disappeared

High commercial rents, rising taxes, the flavored-tobacco restrictions, limits on the number of tobacco retail licenses and the ban on indoor smoking have all made New York a hard place to run a tobacco shop. Shops that survive often combine retail with a lounge or membership club. For the long view, read New York cigar history.

Frequently Asked Questions

When was Barclay Rex founded?

Barclay Rex was founded in 1910 by Vincent Nastri and is still run by the Nastri family.

Where is Barclay Rex now?

Barclay Rex has been at 126 Pearl Street in the Financial District since 2016.

Is the Nat Sherman Townhouse still open?

No. Altria closed Nat Sherman International in 2020, including the 42nd Street townhouse.

Who owns Nat Sherman cigars now?

In 2021 a company formed by former Nat Sherman employees acquired brands including Timeless, Metropolitan, Epoca and Ancora.

Is there a Davidoff shop in New York?

Yes, Davidoff of Geneva has a boutique on Madison Avenue in Manhattan.